User8801_7_t Mary McKnight
Find real estate listings in your city:
Members: 120,713 - 2,150 Online Now  Login
 

In the last few months I have heard epic tales of the Google Sandbox. I’ve had clients tell me it’s an urban legend and others say their site is “permanently sandboxed and they have no hope of crawling up the search results because of it.” In fact, the Google Sandbox has created such a buzz among both the web community and website owners alike, that I feel compelled to set the record straight.


the Google Sandbox?

The Google Sandbox is a filter placed on new websites. The result is a site does not receive good rankings for its most important keywords and keyword phrases. Even with good content, abundant incoming links and strong Google PageRank, a site is still adversely affected by the Sandbox effect. The Sandbox acts as a de facto probation for sites, possibly to discourage spam sites from rising quickly, getting banned, and repeating the process.

The Google Sandbox is a place where Google houses new websites. Sandboxed sites can be considered to be on a “probationary period.” While in the sandbox, sites are demoted in the search results from where they would be expected to be found. Essentially, sandboxed sites are not credited full value for their incoming links and content.

SANDBOX EFFECT: New sites rankings were seen as poor despite good Google PageRanks, strong incoming link totals, and overall good optimization practices being employed.

Why does Google have a Sandbox?

The reason Google created the Sandbox new site filter, was to stop spam related sites from adding numerous purchased links, and ranking highly for their keywords from their launch date. Since Google apparently considers a high number of links pointing to a site from the beginning to be rather suspicious, the links are not considered to be natural. Another possibility is spam sites would use various tactics to rise to the top of the search results, and gain heavy sales prior to being banned for being in violation of Google’s Terms of Service; and then repeating the process continually. As a result, new sites are put into a form of probation, usually referred to as the Google Sandbox.

What types of sites are Sandboxed?

New websites seeking rankings for highly competitive keyword phrases are primarily impacted by the Sandbox. All sites are likely given a term in the Sandbox, but those websites seeking rankings in highly competitive searches, are probably in for a much longer Sandbox stay.

Which sites have not been Sandboxed?

  1. Domains purchased and websites launched prior to the March 2004 implementation of the Google Sandbox avoided the Sandbox effect altogether.

  2. Websites targeting non-competitive keywords and phrases are often left out of the Sandbox as there is little point in applying the filter to them. Sometimes these sites are sandboxed temporarily but sites with less competitive search terms have been found to have much shorter stays in the Sandbox.

How long is a site in the Sandbox?

Sandbox probationary periods vary from one to six months but the most typical term is between three and four months. Less competitive searches will be given the much shorter stay, while more competitive keywords will spend six months or more in the Sandbox.

Essentially, the more competitive the keyword, the longer the site spends in the Sandbox. The effect of the Sandbox filter will gradually decrease over time, and will lose most of its dampening effect in about three months.

How to tell if you’ve been Sandboxed

Evidence of Sandbox activity usually is spotted by having good Google PageRank and incoming links, and strong search results in some secondary search phrases, but the site nowhere to be found for the most important searches. In such cases, it is likely the site has been placed in the Sandbox.

One of the most important characteristics, and indeed one of the marks of being in the Sandbox, is the continuation of strong placements for less important keywords. The Sandbox filter is designed to concern itself with the more competitive keywords as they are more likely to have spam sites, purchased and other links Google deems unnatural, and probably more manipulation attempts being made. That is far less likely in unimportant and non-competitive keywords, so they are generally left alone and out of the Sandbox filter.

How to tell the difference between the Sandbox and a Google penalty

If a site were suffering from a Google penalty, the site would not appear in the Google search engine results pages (SERPs) for even the less important searches. The site would also show no PageRank or even a grey bar on the Google Toolbar.

Buying Google AdWords or Google Adsense will not prevent Sandboxing

Joining programs like Google Adwords and Google Adsense will have no effect on your site’s duration in the Sandbox. Those paid programs could provide much needed traffic while your site remains in the depths of the Sandbox, however. Participation in the various Google advertising programs will not keep your site out of Sandbox, or shorten your stay, despite what some myths would have you believe.

Can you avoid or minimize the effect of the Sandbox?

Not really. You have to serve your time gracefully. Depending on the competitiveness of your most important keywords, that time can vary from one to six months. What you can do is make good use of your time by continuing to improve your site, and be prepared to make a rapid rise once the Sandbox probation ends.

What should I do while my site is in the Sandbox?

While your site is in the Sandbox, it’s an ideal time to add fresh keyword rich content and new incoming links to your site. Adding incoming links will ensure that your site avoids any possible new link dampening filter that might be in effect. By the time your site is out of the Sandbox, your links will be well aged, and ready to pass along their full value of PageRank and link popularity, as the site rises from the depths of the Sandbox.

Your website’s stay in the Sandbox is an ideal time to add more theme and keyword relevant content. Concentrate on adding more keyword rich pages, and don’t forget both on page and off page factors. On the page, make sure your title tags match the most important keywords for that page. Add a site map and be sure that all of your pages link properly to one another with appropriate link anchor text containing the keywords for that page. Off page link anchor text should be set up to include keywords for the receiving page as well. Don’t waste any of your available site improvement time while in the Sandbox. When the filter is lifted, your improved site will rise rapidly to its proper place at the top of the search rankings.

How can I avoid being placed in the Sandbox in the first place?

The Sandbox can be avoided to a degree by purchasing a domain in advance and placing a splash screen up on you destination server. RSS Pieces always places splash screens up during development of new sites/blogs and often tells clients to spend this period of time tailoring their content and reading our SEO documentation so they are prepared for the Sandbox effect and ready for their post Sandbox rankings and traffic. While the site will endure low rankings while in the Sandbox, remember, this is temporary and good SEO will kick start those post Sandbox rankings.

What to do during your Sandbox stay:

  1. Be sure to add as many incoming links as possible to get past the new links filter.

  2. Keep adding content to your site.

 

43 Comments on Google Sandbox: Secrets Revealed

I'm happy I avoided all of that. We get great page rankings and show up on the top 3 of a lot of Google searches...

Scott

10/14/2006 11:09 AM by Oak Valley Mortgage-California Home Loans and Refinancing


Hey Mary what do kind of incoming links would you suggest.  Thanks again for the great post.  SC

10/14/2006 11:10 AM by Steve Campbell (Century 21 Commonwealth Real Estate)


Mary that explains a lot on what my site may have happened to me last year or so. I could never understand why my site ranked great for less important keywords and not for the most important ones. I blamed it on my on site and off site optimization techniques. Thanks for the 411 on the Sandbox

10/14/2006 11:24 AM by Barnett Associates Real Estate, LLC


Incomming links:

Growing backlinks naturally is the key.  If you build them too fast, you get penalized so a natural growth of backlinks should take about 5-6 months.  After a 5-6 month campaign a you shouldn't have to focus that heavily on it- since they should be growing on their own.  Your campaign should be a multi-pronged appoach that includes at least one PRWeb press release, directory submissions (at least 300 with PR 6 or above- grown slowly over -5-6 months), link bait tools (permanent homepage mashup (web app)/lead capture tool), posts comments on related blogs regularly and an automated ping service that will notify social engines and Google when content is updated for increased crawls.  The combination of those tools over a 5-6 month campaign should result in a healthy backlink number of at least 1000 new quality backlinks.  For proof of a growing site:  We launched the RSSPieces domain in early August and we already have a PR 3 and almost 600 backlinks (http://www.seomoz.org/tools/page-strength.php?url=www.rsspieces.com).  We anticipate a PR 5-6 withint 6-8 months and more than 1500 backlinks within one year.  We want to grow our backlinks conservatively but consistantly to get the most out of their SEO value. 

Directory marketing: here is a good site:  

Best Web Directories

they submit links slowly over time and hand edit them so it doesn't look like a submission automater.   Also post yourself in RE relates directories.  I may write a post on this soon.

10/14/2006 11:58 AM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Great information ty Mary. I read this post and realized I had no idea! I like that it's a protection of sorts and in reality, there is a 'curve time' for most websites anyway as we all learn how to make them really good. Google sure gets a lot of attention on AR!  Thanks again.

10/14/2006 12:28 PM by Carole Cohen Realtor®, ePRO (Howard Hanna Cleveland City Office)


DYNAMITE post. "You've been added as an associate..." :)

This sets my mind at ease. We built a new website in August and our rankings .. well, they jumped into the sandbox!

Mary, I wonder if it would help if we removed "real estate" from our meta tags since we serve the real estate industry but don't sell it?

Dawn Shaffer

10/14/2006 01:15 PM by Dawn Shaffer Photography and Hi Def Virtual Tours (All About Virtual Tours, LLC)


Mary,

I got so into reading your response, that I forgot what I wanted to ask!

Your posts here are great.

I bought a lot of domains in '05 and have used them as pointers to pages in my site.  Is that any better or worse than a splash screen?

Thanks,

Maureen 

10/14/2006 01:17 PM by Maureen Francis & Dmitry Koublitsky, SKBK Sotheby's - Metro Detroit (SKBK Sotheby's International Realty)


Hey Maureen- send me a link to one of the pointer pages, I have to look at the code to answer that question.

10/14/2006 01:25 PM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Excellent info.  Quick question.  Can you get sandboxed or have other negative effects when you switch web hosting providers.  I lost some ground after switching not too long ago and wondered if that was a factor or simply tweaked the wrong things.

Thanks for your post.

10/14/2006 01:27 PM by Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation


Those crazy sandboxes!  My site was sandboxed for 6 months..LOL.  I was quite angry about it.  The good thing is at least you have time to get your content and links up.

Canton Real Estate

10/14/2006 01:45 PM by Jennifer K Giraldi, Atlanta REALTOR® Atlanta Real Estate Expert (Solid Source Realty Atlanta)


yes, you can lose some ground when switching web providers.  There are many many reasons for that.  But one of the most prevelant is that if you are not the sole site on your box you could have gone to a "bad neighborhood."  Which means some of the other sites on the server are "bad seeds."  So, you can get punished by Google and others for their mistakes.

10/14/2006 01:45 PM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


I gave up on key word positioning.. pay-per-click, thats the way to go! No fuss no Muss! LOL

10/14/2006 01:59 PM by Rod Randolph - Arizona Realtor (Signature Realty / Signature Rent To Own)


Even ActiveRain is impacted pretty heavily by this sandbox, or more correctly Google filters.  The growth rate of this site has been so high in the 5 months since launch, with thousands of incoming links and new pages of content that it almost certainly looks unnatural.

One good indicator is our placement for a highly competitive key term "real estate agents".  Within 1 month after launch we moved to about #85 for that term.  Despite the huge amounts of growth we haven't budged in the last four months.  Comparing this site to others for dozens of criteria, there's no reason we shouldn't be ranking in the top 10, if it wasn't for tripping filters.  With time we'll break out of those filters but so much of SEO is simply about patience.

Despite this we tend to rank very highly quickly for long tailed search, which is generating several thousand visitors off of Google per day.  It's hard not to get frustrated but we've built large sites in the past and have seen it all before.  You have a great site, don't show up in the top results for 6 months and then out of the blue your in top position bringing in thousands of visitors :)

10/14/2006 03:16 PM by Matt Heaton (ActiveRain Corp.)


One thing I would like to add is you can take a site that is old and get it sent to the sandbox. If you out start adding a bunch of links when previously you hadn't been getting any you run the chance of sending any site to the sandbox. Older and more established the site is the lower the risk, but just because your site is a year old doesn't mean you wil not go to the sandbox if you start adding links in an overly agressive way.

10/14/2006 04:04 PM by Ken Smith (Suburban House Hunters)


I can understand that.  A year ago we worked on a site/web app for a division of Exxon.  Can you even imagine how hard it was for this new site to rank in the top 10 for the term "Exxon?"  Imagine being Exxon itself and not ranking in the top 10 in Google for your onw name for over 8 months.  

10/14/2006 04:04 PM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Every time I read your blog I leave feeling like a complete idiot, but that's a compliment.  I had never even heard of the Google Sandbox until this blog.  Thanks again for the expert info and advice.

10/14/2006 05:35 PM by Steven Holcomb, Esq. - BBA, JD, GRI (Keller Williams Realty)


However keep in mind the Sandbox is a THEORY.  Google has never officially mentioned a sandbox, nor they state anything whatsoever related to a 'sandbox'.


There are VERY few 'facts' regarding search engine optimization.  Most of what you read are 'theories' based on prior experiences - and that is not necessarily a bad thing.  But there is VERY little factual information, and that pertains to this supposed 'sandbox'.  

Search engines will tell you very little about what they are looking for and what they are doing - otherwise once you figure it out it's easy to 'manipulate' results and get your site to the top - exactly what they DON'T want.

I agree with much of what is said here, however NONE is factual and all is based on theory and more importantly, subject to change at any time when Google changes their algorythms.

10/14/2006 06:08 PM by Mary Ellison


huh. i have never heard of this. thanks for bringing it up.

cheers,

 

cindy 

10/14/2006 06:18 PM by Cindy Lin @ Staged4more, ASPM, IAHSP,IRIS, CSP (Staged4more Home Staging & Redesigns)


Mary...AGAIN...I am so glad I added you as an associate....

my central florida real estate website spent ONE YEAR in the sandbox...for the keyword "orlando real estate"...a HIGHLY competitive keyword..... at times it has searches in the 50,000 per month range....

When I got out of the sandbox the results were dramatic...... I am still NOT ranked or I am in the hundreds for the key word before mentioned, BUT I am number 15 for the keyword "orlando MLS"...I am on page 2...hehehehehe

I am so glad you told me what had happened to my site...I have about 900 incoming links from other websites..... I only have about 200 outgoing links from my site to others....

:-D

 

10/14/2006 06:42 PM by Central / Orlando Florida real estate - Alexander Harb PSEM®, E-Agent® (Beach and Luxury Realty Inc.)


WOW! Mary, how did you learn about all this insider stuff? I'm glad ActiveRain added bookmarks, I'll be using it on this post.

10/14/2006 07:06 PM by Sharon Simms St Pete Florida CRS CIPS CLHMS (RE/MAX Metro)


Proof of the sandbox: Google's own patent calls out for the "dampening" of links based on age.  So what we as SEOs call the "sandbox" is what Google calls a dampening filter.  Google admits the existance of these in their patent and recently Matt Cutts has even elluded to them.

Patent thesis on SEO moz regarding the sandbox.

Also a recent crash of some google servers emitted some very interesting data that basically proved the sandbox exists.  You can google that.

10/14/2006 07:18 PM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Hmm, so much to think about. I wonder if my marketing guy knows all of this. I hope so!

Thank you for the insight!

10/14/2006 07:19 PM by Natasha Perez (Century 21 Alll Service)


Another information-loaded post. Great learning. Thanks for your continued info-sharing.

10/14/2006 07:20 PM by Jeff Dowler ~ Carlsbad Real Estate ~ 760-840-1360 (RE/MAX Associates)


Insteresting Mary, very interesting...more food for thought. I remember when the info was released but that was when I was an ultra newb in the SEO world.

10/14/2006 07:37 PM by Barnett Associates Real Estate, LLC


Who Knew!  I guess I am lucky that some of the domain names I am using have been in service since 2002.

10/14/2006 07:39 PM by Teresa Boardman (Keller Williams)


Lots of Matt Cutt's post talk about various filters that can get tripped.  Too many incoming links, content added to fast, over optimization of pages.  While they never call is a "sandbox" the fact that these filters exist isn't in dispute. 

10/14/2006 08:02 PM by Matt Heaton (ActiveRain Corp.)


What can be considered over optimization of a page?

10/14/2006 08:03 PM by Barnett Associates Real Estate, LLC


here is good article explaining over optimization

ALSO: 

Matt- Thanks for the support in proving that, yes indeedy, Google dampening filters (sandbox) do exist.

10/14/2006 08:42 PM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Good article Mary, and after reading there is something that Bill uses as example which I am currently doing :( Guess its something to edit right away.

10/14/2006 08:47 PM by Barnett Associates Real Estate, LLC


It seems to do its job fairly effecctively. Websites are for the turtles that plug along day after day. Ken glad to see you blogging again. We will have to invite Bob Wilson so he can exchange ideas will Mary.

10/14/2006 10:06 PM by Eric Bouler (Prudential Gardner)


Very interesting. Thank you.

Jay and Lilnnea Hanley

10/14/2006 11:07 PM by Jay and Linnea Hanley (PrudentialFloridaRealty)


Google is a powerful tool, thanks for the inside information

10/14/2006 11:51 PM by Eddy Martinez (Nationwide Funding Group)


Mary does yahoo or anyone else use sandboxing.

10/15/2006 09:19 AM by John Rogers (Century 21 APD)


Does Google publish this information anywhere - or is this info gleaned by experience?

10/15/2006 10:32 AM by Suzanne Marriott, Associate Broker, CLHMS, e-PRO (Keller Williams Realty Professional Partners)


This is fact.  You can read the Google Patents to see that what SEOs call the Sandbox, is what Google calls new site dampening filters.  I posted a comment above that gave all the links.  Check it out.

10/15/2006 10:49 AM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Hi Mary,

 

I have a website that is ran by the company (Wells Fargo) and I would like to get better rankings, preferably in my general location.  Any way to do this?  I purchased several domain names that point to my website, and have inquired with some local computer gurus as to what I can do to pull my site to the top but they tell me I can't because I don't manage the site....

 Is that correct?

Thanks,

 

Jim

10/16/2006 08:11 AM by Jim Williamson


Get your own site. You can rank any site with enough off page SEO, but it can be really hard (and expensive) if the on page SEO isn't also done.

10/17/2006 11:15 AM by Ken Smith (Suburban House Hunters)


I'll second getting your own website then you will never have to worry about loosing your website if you decide to leave your current company.

10/17/2006 02:39 PM by Barnett Associates Real Estate, LLC


Jim, definitely get your own website.   Ken and Toby are smart guys, they know what they are talking baout.

10/17/2006 05:53 PM by Mary McKnight (1parkplace)


Thanks for the helpful information.... I learned a lot from your post!!  Keep up the great work...

11/01/2006 03:48 AM by Bill Sauneuf (Preview Properties Skagit LLC)


Mary,

Thank you for all the helpful information and giving me tips both personally and on this forum. It is great learning the difference between the sandbox and being penalized by google. Thanks for all the tips.

08/25/2008 01:48 AM by Birmingham Alabama Real Estate Jason Secor (Powell Properties)


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Real Estate - Other: Mary McKnight (1parkplace)
Mary McKnight
Orlando, FL
More about me…
1parkplace

Office Phone: (407) 572-4638
Email Me
Helping Realtors learn to successfully write and promote their real estate blog. Online success is not magic, it's knowledge and most of time, it’s free. My focus is to give Realtors the tools and knowledge to affordably succeed online through search engine optimization, search engine marketing, blogging and proper RSS implementation.


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find FL real estate agents and Orlando real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved